Start with eligibility, not the advertised payment
FHA loans are broadly available to qualified borrowers, while VA-backed loans require eligible military service or another qualifying relationship. A payment comparison is useful only after confirming that both choices are genuinely available.
Compare every cost in the same scenario
Use the same purchase price, down payment, loan term, rate, property taxes, and homeowners insurance. Then add FHA mortgage insurance or the applicable VA funding fee so the comparison does not hide program-specific costs.
- Cash needed at closing
- Principal and interest
- Taxes and homeowners insurance
- Mortgage insurance or funding fee
- Total interest during the expected holding period
Choose using the holding period and flexibility
A loan with a lower initial cash requirement may cost more over time. Test several down payments and holding periods, and compare the calculator result with lender disclosures before committing.
A same-price comparison worksheet
Suppose a home costs $300,000. A hypothetical 5% down payment is $15,000 and leaves $285,000 before financed fees; a zero-down scenario starts at $300,000. These are comparison assumptions, not program eligibility or minimum-down-payment claims. At the same rate and term, the different principal alone changes principal-and-interest payments.
Enter both scenarios separately. Add only the insurance and funding fees that apply to each actual offer, then record cash at closing and monthly tax, insurance and loan costs. For example, a quoted $120 monthly insurance cost adds $7,200 over 60 months only if that charge remains unchanged throughout. Do not assume an upfront fee and a monthly charge are interchangeable. Before deciding, compare lender disclosures and any applicable exemption or insurance cancellation terms.
- Keep purchase price and holding period the same.
- List upfront and monthly charges in separate columns.
- Check program eligibility with the lender, not this worksheet.
Test your scenario
Use the related calculators
The guide frames the comparison; the calculators let you enter your own numbers and test alternatives.