Separate the required payment from your cash budget
For balance P, monthly rate r and n remaining payments: when r > 0, the scheduled payment is P × r / (1 − (1 + r)^(−n)). When r = 0, the scheduled payment is P / n. A fixed monthly budget C must be at least the scheduled payment; extra principal is C minus that scheduled payment. Interest each month is the opening balance × r; principal is the payment minus interest. A lower scheduled payment becomes more principal, not spare cash, when C stays unchanged.
The simple cash break-even formula is net upfront fees divided by actual monthly cash savings. It is useful only when those savings are positive and the compared debt balances and terms are understood. In the same-budget example below, all three paths spend $2,500 monthly: there is no monthly cash saving to put in that denominator. Compare cumulative outflow and remaining debt instead.
Add the costs a simple formula can miss
All paths below start with the same existing $300,000 debt. Paying a $6,000 refinance fee in cash keeps new principal at $300,000 but requires $6,000 at closing. Financing that same fee starts the new loan at $306,000: no fee cash leaves at closing, but interest accrues on the larger debt. Do not add the financed fee again to the cash-paid fee line. Equal monthly budgets do not mean equal upfront cash commitments; a plan that instead puts available $6,000 into the old principal needs a separate calculation.
To reproduce the table, use the extra-payment calculator with each displayed principal, rate and contract term; set monthly extra to $2,500 minus the scheduled payment, and set annual and lump-sum extras to zero. Use the unrounded scheduled payment for that subtraction; entering only the table’s rounded cents can slightly change the final cents. The refinance calculator separately compares contractual payments with cash-paid closing costs; it does not directly model this fixed-budget, financed-fee table. Neither model includes taxes, insurance, changed PMI, prepayment penalties, opportunity returns or daily-interest posting. Recalculate if these differ between actual offers.
- Cash paid at closing versus fees in the opening loan balance
- Contract term versus payoff month under continued extras
- Cumulative interest and debt at the same holding date
Compare the same horizon, not different lifetime totals
At a common holding month H, compare cash paid through H, including any cash closing fee, plus the loan balance after that month’s payment. Subtracting the same starting $300,000 debt leaves interest and financing costs in this simplified comparison. For a financed fee, its $6,000 is already in the debt balance and is counted once. No discounting or return on retained cash is assumed, and the result is not cash profit or a guaranteed benefit.
At month 60, none of the example loans is paid off. If the same $2,500 budget and fixed rates continue, payoff occurs at payment 195, 175 or 181, with a smaller final payment. These future payoff months are projections, not five-year savings. A 30-year refinance contract has a lower minimum but does not itself promise earlier payoff; lowering your actual payment to that minimum changes the comparison. Test earlier and later holding dates and compare real quotes before deciding.
Compare three paths over the same 60 months
Start with $300,000 of existing debt, a 60-month holding period and $2,500 paid each month. Keep the old loan at a hypothetical 6.5% with 20 years remaining, or refinance at an illustrative 5.5% for 30 years. Refinance fees are $6,000, either paid separately in cash or added to new principal. These rates and fees are assumptions, not current offers. Interest uses annual rate / 12 and payment at month-end; all excess above the required payment goes immediately to principal. Intermediate calculations retain precision; displayed money is rounded to cents.
The cash-fee refinance shows $72,509.07 of interest plus a $6,000 fee over 60 months, versus $88,160.28 interest on the old-loan extra-payment path. The financed-fee refinance shows $74,403.30 interest plus the same $6,000 embedded fee. Their simplified borrowing costs are therefore $78,509.07 and $80,403.30, respectively, not the interest figures alone. Comparing outflow plus remaining debt gives a conditional cost difference of $9,651.20 or $7,756.98 relative to the old-loan path. This is not cash received, an investment return or a comparison of full-lifetime interest.
- Keep the $2,500 monthly budget in every path.
- Count a financed fee once, through debt, not again as closing cash.
- Payoff-month projections assume the same rates and budget continue.
Scroll sideways for all columns; keyboard users can use the left and right arrow keys.
| Measure | Keep loan + extra principal | Refinance; fee paid in cash | Refinance; fee financed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening modeled loan balance | $300,000.00 | $300,000.00 | $306,000.00 |
| Fixed rate / contract term | 6.5% / 20 years | 5.5% / 30 years | 5.5% / 30 years |
| Cash fee at closing | $0.00 | $6,000.00 | $0.00 |
| Scheduled monthly principal and interest | $2,236.72 | $1,703.37 | $1,737.43 |
| Monthly extra principal | $263.28 | $796.63 | $762.57 |
| Monthly cash payment | $2,500.00 | $2,500.00 | $2,500.00 |
| Interest paid through month 60 | $88,160.28 | $72,509.07 | $74,403.30 |
| Balance after payment 60 | $238,160.28 | $222,509.07 | $230,403.30 |
| 60-month cash outflow including closing fee | $150,000.00 | $156,000.00 | $150,000.00 |
| Cash outflow + remaining debt | $388,160.28 | $378,509.07 | $380,403.30 |
| 60-month interest and fee cost | $88,160.28 | $78,509.07 | $80,403.30 |
| Lower modeled cost versus keeping the loan | $0.00 | $9,651.20 | $7,756.98 |
| Payoff payment if the same budget continues | 195 | 175 | 181 |
Test your scenario
Use the related calculators
The guide frames the comparison; the calculators let you enter your own numbers and test alternatives.